Assessing the Show Quality of Poultry

Article by Laura Haggarty

Part of my problem with critiquing a bird based on photos alone is that photos only show a small part of the story.

Photos can be very deceptive. Color can be off, black can show up that isn't there, and the angle of a photo can make a bird look wider or longer or shorter than it really is.

To really assess a bird, you have to pick them up, feel their weight, feel the straightness of their keels, feel the depth of their breasts and the width of their chests, and feel the straightness of their pelvic bones.

Photos only show half the story. It’s why a judge opens a cage and takes bird out when he judges it. If that weren’t important, they wouldn’t bother, they’d just walk down the line and make their decision based on looks alone. But looks are not all there is too it. Weight, feather quality, and all the rest is so important.

This is why I won't comment on someone's "line" whose birds I have never seen, much less handled. If I haven't handled your birds, I can't begin to make a comment on them, because I don't really know what they're like.

So when someone goes online and starts critiquing other people's lines and they haven't actually handled the birds, I say, take that criticism with a big grain of salt, because they may be basing their comments on hearsay, photos, and stuff they read elsewhere.

And no one should ever base their breeding program on how a given bird does at a show either. Anyone who does is doing themselves a disservice. Just because a given bird wins at a given show or two doesn't necessarily mean the bird should become the foundation for your breeding program. There are other factors that should be considered as well. Remember, it's just one judge looking at your bird on one day. How does the bird look the other 364 days of the year? That is so much more important.

What can we help you find? Search the website:

Subscribe to the PSC Insiders Newsletter

* indicates required

Please select the newsletter you wish to receive :

By clicking below, you agree to receive emails from PSC.

Note:  Did you subscribe but haven't been receiving a newsletter in your inbox?  Search your Spam or Promotions Tab so you don't miss a single issue!  

Return to the Home Page

What's New Around Here?

  1. WA - Barnvelder, Double Laced Partridge

    My name is Linda. We have a small farm in Spokane, WA. I have the large fowl, double-laced partridge Barnvelder. My parent stock was obtained from show

  2. WA - Double Silver Laced Barnevelder

    My name is Linda. We have a small farm in Spokane, WA. I have the wonderful double-laced silver Barnvelder. My chickens are full size fowl. My original

  3. WA - Self-Blue (Lavender) Ameraucana

    My name is Linda. We have a small farm in Spokane, WA. I am breeding show quality “self-blue” (lavender) Ameraucana. These are full size birds not bantams.

  4. WA - Ameraucauna, Blue/Black/Splash (BBS)

    My name is Linda. We have a small farm in Spokane, WA. I have the Blue, Black and Splash combination of Ameraucana. I obtained my parent stock from Gypsy

  5. Wanted: Silver pencil or partridge Wyandotte southern CA

    Does anyone have partridge Wyandotte chicks for sale in Southern CA? (Not Bantum ) Or silver pencil wyandotte chicks? Thank you!!!! Snethepd@verizon.ne

  6. Atlantic Canada Young Bird Classic

    Information on the Atlantic Canada Young Bird Classic